After publishing the paper, Rao got a surprise. The question of which language family the script belongs to, it turns out, is a sensitive one: because of the Indus civilization’s age and significance, many contemporary groups in India would like to claim it as a direct ancestor. For instance, the Tamil-speaking Indians of the south would prefer to learn that the Indus script was a kind of proto-Dravidian, since Tamil is descended from proto-Dravidian. Hindi speakers in the north would rather it be an old form of Sanskrit, an ancestor of Hindi. Rao’s paper doesn’t conclude which language family the script belongs to, though it does note that the conditional entropy is similar to Old Tamil—causing some critics to summarily “accuse us of being Dravidian nationalists,” says Rao. “The ferocity of the accusations and attacks was completely unexpected.” [Can Computers Decipher a 5,000-Year-Old Language?]
Related posts:
- Indus Script: A Formal Language This picture shows a Harappan seal with five inscriptions or characters, which have been undeciphered. In fact there are many decipherments, but no scholarly consensus. One of the disputes...
- A Talk on Indus People and their Script In April 2009, “a team of Indian scientists reports in Friday’s issue of Science journal that the Indus script has a structured sign system showing features of a formal language.”...
- Undeciphered Scripts As the debate over the Indus script – on if it is a language or not and if so, is it Dravidian or Indo-European – continues, New Scientist has an...
- Indian History Carnival – 17 The Indian History Carnival, published on the 15th of every month, is a collection of posts related to Indian history and archaeology. One fundamental dispute regarding the Indus script is...
- Hostile Reactions In 2004, the Dover, Pennysylvania, school board decided to teach students an alternative to evolution called Intelligent Design.Because Darwin’s Theory is a theory, it continues to be tested as new...
Recent Comments