My article at ISN Zurich

While it is distressing that mobs can restrict cultural freedom, liberals should be concerned that our governments too act mala fide with élan. In 2006, The Da Vinci Code, based on a best selling novel of the same name by Dan Brown, was released in India. This controversial novel and movie propagated Donovan Joyce’s 1973 theory that Jesus married Mary Magdalene and their bloodline survives to this day. While it was not banned in Christian majority countries, this movie, which was cleared by the Central Board of Film Certification, was either banned or suspended in Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Nagaland, Meghalaya and Punjab.

My article on Cultural Liberalism was published by ISN Zurich. This article was originally published in Pragati and was also carried by Mail Today.

Kashmir concerns us

The recent violence in Kashmir also bought out the intellectual pygmies in India. They wrote columns advocating the separation of Jammu and Kashmir along religious lines so that they could watch genocide and make a livelihood out of it. These people have serious thrill issues.

During such times, the Sept 2008 issue of Pragati reassures that sanity and historical perspective are present in adequate amounts among foreign policy analysts.

Issue Contents

PERSPECTIVE

Don’t fall for crowd power
India has seen off secessionism before
K Subrahmanyam

No more partitions please, we’re Indians
A united India is the best hope for all its people
Rohit Pradhan, Shashi Shekhar & Sushant K Singh

Liberal solutions
Adopting truly liberal solutions can save Kashmir—and the concept of India itself
Harsh Gupta

Dealing with the Taliban insurgency
Pakistan is yet to evolve a cohesive strategy for its tribal areas
Ayesha Saeed

IN DEPTH
Shaping the neighbourhood
A discussion on strategic affairs with C Raja Mohan
Nitin Pai

IN PARLIAMENT
Reforming land acquisition
Frameworks for acquiring land and rehabilitating affected people
M R Madhavan

ROUNDUP
Pope Gregory VII, Singur and morality
Stealing private property is wrong, even when the state does it
Vipin Veetil

Retail in doldrums
A veritable job-machine is being prevented from starting
Prashant Kumar Singh

More to microfinance than moneylending
A sceptic’s defence of microfinance
Aadisht Khanna

BOOKS
A very brief Kalam
The insubstantial memoirs of a presidential secretary
Samanth Subramanian

Download

The Antikythera mechanism

A recent paper published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, used astronomical references in Odyssey to find the date on which the Greek hero Odysseus returned to his wife Penelope. Using three non-allegorical astronomical references, the researchers searched for a date between 1250 – 1115 B.C.E. where the astronomical references cohered and found that a date of April 16, 1178 B.C.E matched perfectly.

The authors of the paper believe that Odyssey is fiction and it was interpolated with valid astronomical data. But Homer lived five centuries after the eclipse and it is a mystery how he would have known about that event. One theory suggested in the paper is that, if Homer knew about Metonic and Saros eclipse cycles, he could have estimated the eclipse.

In fact the Greeks had a mechanical device which could do exactly that. Though sponge divers discovered the device in 1901, it was only recently that many mysteries of its mysteries were solved. The device called the Antikythera mechanism was thought to be an ancient mechanical computer.

A paper in Nature reveals that one dial on the bronze mechanism is a 19 year calendar based on the Metonic cycle and all 12 months in the calendar were identified. Also it was found that the mechanism was sophisticated enought to know which years had 13 months and which months had 29 or 30 days. The Babylonians too had a Metonic cycle based calendar, but it was not this precise.

Another dial on the mechanism was found to be the Saros eclipse prediction dial with an excellent prediction scheme. 18 eclipse glyphs were marked on the dial and it gave a perfect match for 100 start dates.

Homer could not have known about this particular device since it is dated to 146 BCE, when Corith, where the device was created, fell to Romans. Homer is dated to 8th century BCE and so far so such devices dating to that period have been found. So the mystery of how Homer knew about eclipses five centuries before him still remains.

See Also:

  1. Calendars with Olympiad display and eclipse prediction on the Antikythera Mechanism Tony Freeth1,2,Alexander Jones3, John M. Steele4&Yanis Bitsakis1,5
  2. Supplementary Notes
  3. Video from Nature Magazine

Oh Piye!

In 730 BCE, Egypt was ruled by petty warlords and the civilization which would be the subject of many PBS documentaries had collapsed. One man, Piye, changed all that. In one year he subjugated every warlord and bought Egypt under his control. Piye and his successors not only united Egypt, but added many monuments including pyramids. Piye was a black pharaoh from Nubia (modern Sudan) and the Nubian history goes as far as the first Egyptian dynasty.

The fact that he was black did not matter to the ancient Egyptians. It also did not matter to the Greeks and Romans who knew that he was black and had art depicting it. Then, in the 19th century the Western scholars noticed.

Even famed Harvard Egyptologist George Reisner—whose discoveries between 1916 and 1919 offered the first archaeological evidence of Nubian kings who ruled over Egypt—besmirched his own findings by insisting that black Africans could not possibly have constructed the monuments he was excavating. He believed that Nubia’s leaders, including Piye, were light-skinned Egypto-Libyans who ruled over the primitive Africans. That their moment of greatness was so fleeting, he suggested, must be a consequence of the same leaders intermarrying with the “negroid elements.”

For decades, many historians flip-flopped: Either the Kushite pharaohs were actually “white,” or they were bumblers, their civilization a derivative offshoot of true Egyptian culture. In their 1942 history, When Egypt Ruled the East, highly regarded Egyptologists Keith Seele and George Steindorff summarized the Nubian pharaonic dynasty and Piye’s triumphs in all of three sentences—the last one reading: “But his dominion was not for long.”

The neglect of Nubian history reflected not only the bigoted worldview of the times, but also a cult-like fascination with Egypt’s achievements—and a complete ignorance of Africa’s past.[National Geographic Magazine – NGM.com]

Thus when a native civilization was found to have made great achivements, Western scholars wrote history to change them to light-skinned men who ruled over the dark skinned primitives. Where have we heard this before.?

The Bible's Buried Secrets

What would happen to your religious lives if, hypothetically, all history were voided or made inaccessible to you or somehow falsified beyond hope? In other words, imagine that due to some strange reasons, the details of which are irrelevant, you have to live your lives without having any knowledge passed down from God through any historical events whatsoever. What would you do? Would it be possible for you to lead religious lives, and if so, by what authority would you do so? In other words, can you discover the spiritual truth for yourselves without dependence on historical sources, or would you be lost if such historical sources were simply unavailable or unreliable? [Myth of Hindu Sameness]

That was a question Rajiv Malhotra asked a room full of attorneys in New Jersey and they were stumped. Does this mean that Abrahamic religions are dependent on historical episodes and would be meaningless without them?

On November 18, 2008, PBS is premiering a 2 hour program titled The Bible’s Buried Secrets which “vividly recounts the saga of the ancient Israelites and digs deeply into both the Bible and the history of the Israelites through the archeological artifacts they left behind.” The program tries to find out who wrote the Hebrew Bible and if there is any historical basis to Moses, Abraham, Exodus, and King David.

The findings of the program are not going to make a lot of people happy

But the film challenges long-held beliefs. Abraham, Sarah and their offspring probably didn’t exist, Meyers said.

“These stories are unlikely to represent real historical events, but rather there’s some kernel of ancient experience in there which has survived and which helps give identity to the people at the time the Bible finally took shape centuries and centuries later,” Meyers said.

There’s no archaeological evidence of the Exodus, either, Meyers said. “It doesn’t mean that there’s no kernel of truth to it,” she said.

Apsell said she found it “extremely shocking” to learn that monotheism was a process that took hundreds of years.[Orlando Sentinel – “Bible’s Buried Secrets” from PBS’ ]

Already online petitions are up calling for an end public funding for PBS.

Columnists and Secessionists

“According to the Pentagon today, secret surrender negotiations are now underway with key Iraqi military officials. That’s what the Pentagon said: We’re in secret negotiations, so for God sakes, don’t tell anyone. … What we’re doing basically is giving these key Iraqi military officials instructions on how to surrender. See, this is where we could have used the French.” —Jay Leno

In India, we don’t need the French.Esteemed columnists like Swaminathan Aiyar and Vir Sanghvi have called upon the nation to wave the white flag and kneel before the secessionists. We should thank our stars (or Richard Dawkins if you are an atheist) that such people did not exist in 1947.

On August 15, 1947, when India became Independent, the Maharajah of Kashmir signed a standstill agreement with the government of Pakistan, a precursor to accession. The Pakistanis also took over charge of Jammu and Kashmir’s post and telegraph system, food supplies and essential commodities. But in September armed groups from Pakistan came from West Punjab and started looting and raping the the Muslims in Kashmir valley, the same people whom they had come to liberate.

A desperate Maharajah turned to India. Even though Chacha Nehru and Lord Mountabatten were running the show, they got the Maharajah to sign the Instrument of Accession and Kashmir joined the Indian Union. If these columnists were around at that time, they would have taken umbrage at the Maharajah for not letting his people be murdered.

In 1965 several thousand armed men — mainly professional Pakistani soldiers and non-Kashmiris — crossed the Line Of Control to liberate Kashmir. The Kashmirs stood by India but our columnists would have encouraged them to surrender.

In the 80s Sikh separatism was a major problem in India. Delhi was a fortress and Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale used to run the show from the Golden Temple. Our columnists would have written op-eds praising him and would have flown the Khalistan flag in their homes.

These are your regular columnists. Then there the award winning types – the Booker and the like. They missed the 1947 and 1971 genocides. The ones they saw in 1984 and 2002 were not up to their standards. They now want a Balkanization of Jammu and Kashmir so that they will get fodder for some books, columns and lucrative speeches on the speaking circuit.

These grandees are not confined by the parochial boundaries of nations. They are mobile republics who unfortunately were born in India. Instead of floating in international waters like true mobile republics, they live prosperously in the comforts of the Indian state carrying out the ISI agenda of a death by thousand cuts.

All of them — the regular and award winning ones — claim they are drinking the liberalism Kool-Aid. It is time they checked the contents of the bottle because this drink tastes like communalism. They encourage communalism and want the division of India along communal lines and call others communal. As Plato once said to Aristotle: If it walks like a duck…

Instead let me suggest a new drink. Liberal Nationalism. Neither shaken nor stirred.

The Workers Paradise

With the Soviet archives opening up, more details of the Communist paradise are finding the light of the day. The antics of the saints who adorn the wall of Communist party offices in India can now be read in Paul R. Gregory’s Lenin’s Brain and Other Tales from the Secret Soviet Archives. This includes details of Stalin’s Great Terror of 1937-38 when 700,000 people were shot dead and the murder of 21, 857 Polish POWs in 1939. According to a Newsweek review, the book “reveals Stalin and his successors as trigger-happy liars who never saw a fact they couldn’t twist.”

Such moving stories explain why this slim book is just the right antidote to the often daunting studies most scholars produce after working in the archives. The hefty books certainly serve their purpose. But Gregory has wisely chosen to reach out to a broader audience by providing a highly accessible primer on the deadly workings of the state that proclaimed itself the workers’ paradise. In the process he provides a timely reminder of how quickly a utopian vision can be transformed into a nightmarish reality.[Declassifying the Kremlin | Newsweek Books | Newsweek.com]

Indian History Carnival – 8

The Indian History Carnival, published on the 15th of every month, is a collection of posts related to Indian history and archaeology.

  1. Namit Arora travels to Dholavira, a 5000 year old metropolis of the Indus Valley Civilization and is impressed by their water management system.

  2. Nitin at The Acorn has been reading Arthashastra and he has four posts on friend, gold and territory, sovereignty, power and happiness, internal security and declaring war

  3. It was fate and Rudyard Kipling that brought Mark Twain to India. In a well researched post Maddy writes about Mark Twain’s India trip in 1895.

  4. Chandrahas at The Middle Stage has a review of Vinay Lal’s The Other Indians which “meticulously charts the progress of Indian life in America from trickle to flood, stammer to swagger.”

  5. In 1931 Gandhiji was asked if he would agree to be the Prime Minister of the future government of India and he replied he would not. Instead, Vishal writes, Gandhiji carefully selected disciples from all over India who would provide leadership even when the Father of the Nation was gone.

  6. The Salt Tax which Gandhiji opposed was not a British invention, but something which existed in India since the Mauryan time. The British just multiplied it by a humongous number. Fëanor has a history of Salt Tax.

  7. As Western scholars set the rules for historical research — a very different one from that practised in their own research centers — we need to evaluate what can be done. This was the theme of the post Our Voice in Our History at varnam. This was published in Pragati as well as in Mail Today.

  8. What is historical thinking? R S Krishna explains.

If you find any posts related to Indian history published in the past one month, please send it to jk AT varnam DOT org or use this form. Please send me links which are similar to the ones posted, in terms of content.The next carnival will be up on Sep 15th.

See Also: Previous Carnivals

My Op-Ed in Mail Today: Our Voice

Photobucket
My article, Our Voice in Our History, published in the Aug 2008 edition of Pragati was printed in Mail Today.
Their editor sensationalized the title of the article to, We don’t quite get it, the first globalized civilization was in India which demonstrated that the person who did not quite get it was the copy writer who came with the title. In the article I make no claims that India was the first globalized civilization. The article was not about proving it either but about the need for more voices in Indic studies. As it stands now there is disconnect between the title of the article and contents.
Now, back to the break.